Difference between revisions of "Development"

Revision as of 21:24, 17 May 2011

Roadmap

Weekly Meetings

May 17, 2011

Add comments, bugs, critiques, etc. about the 2.0 changes here

Global variables
- Check issue on MacOS
- Add documentation

Mashups [Emanuele]
- on track, separate feedback
- switching vistrails issue
- execute button move --- move to right side (and make it possible to disable)
- how does execute work
- close builder window doesn't trigger quit?

Provenance view [Tommy]
- read all provenance right now
- create an index file in the vt to load pieces of provenance on demand
- enhancement idea: highlight errors in the list view of Log Details
- tooltips in the browser view show large icons
- search for provenance browser
- fix issues with the left box
- number of search boxes...

Update splash screen [Juliana will talk to Nathan]

Go over Jan's feedback on the PythonSource editor

A slight UI glitch is that I couldn't access the undo/redo functionality with the usual Cmd+[Shift+]Z shortcuts (neither via the menu or toolbars) but only via the right mouse button. One additional feature that might be nice in the future would be some minimal indentation assistance, like when pressing [Return] the current indentation is kept for the new line.

May 2, 2011

Demos of new 2.0 functionality:
- Mashup
  - log issue: break the link between vistrail.log and controller.log...
  - experimental version so we can play with it and see if there are issues, what improvements
- Provenance browser
  - waiting to merge
- PythonSource editor
  - compile for windows, check how it works on Mac
  - issue with multiple windows?
- Global variables
  - expressions with variable, wait on this
  - set parameters on vistrail
  - click on ports to associate with globals

Bug fixes
- Web services
  - upgrades are working
  - Upgrades are in a separate package
  - hooks in vistrails to allow detection when a package is not loaded

Apr 26, 2011

Updates:
- Mashup
  - easier ways to generate package wrappers
  - working on merging code
- Provenance browser
  - fixed thumbnails to show larger thumbnails
  - via tooltip?
  - keeping separate branch right now, detailed commit message on merge
- Persistence Package
  - stand-alone browser for writing and deleting files
  - writing annotations for execution provenance
  - find where version is not being written as an execution annotation
- bug: upgrade and Web services
  - last modified header not in all http transfers (e.g. for wsdl)
  - how to track versions of web services
  - one package per wsdl? see if this will work
  - seems to be an issue with network and that server (have to lookup twice)
- Global variables
  - next week demo
- new GUI

- v2.0 branch
  - keep mashups off master
  - merging is pretty good using git
  - changing to a single-window interface, adding menus back

Decide:
- PythonSource editor
  - try Eric or some QScintilla-based approach

Apr 18, 2011

2.0 Release: new features to be included and bug fixes
- Mashup
  - if already have alias, carry these over
  - have ability to choose GUI elements
  - storing provenance
  - allow users to import aliases, but don't write back to vistrail unless users wants to
  - provide user
  - create new palette for showing information about subworkflows and mashups (and tagged workflows) that shows on the left side [Dave]
- Provenance browser
  - Index for provenance information
  - Showing this in a separate tab, linking to a existing workflow
- Global variables
  - create a separate window
  - have underlying code for this
- control-flow assistant
  - Dan send documentation to Juliana and Claurissa
- Updated documentation
  - especially for executable paper
  - mashups
- Feature 'executable publications' more prominently
- FIX: upgrade and Web services
- Python editor
  - indentation and coloring
  - modeless window

Updates
- Workflow search [Tommy]
  - can now save multiple objects to the database in two round trips (modulo number of groups)
  - create bigger thumbnails using tooltip in Ubuntu
  - view pipeline execution with groups
  - qbe. indexing high-level overview to Tommy
- Global variables [Daniel]
- Mashup integration [Emanuele]
- Python source editor [Emanuele]
- Web services update [Dan]
  - don't have upgrades
  - version numbers for web services modules, detect via some type of hashing
  - use last modified date + hash

Apr 12, 2011

Workflow search [Tommy]
- Thumbnails in search
- Workflow search for individual workflows
- Materialize workflows: user-controlled for now, button in search interface to materialize workflows
- 2.0: log search for sure, possibly workflow/execution search
- Show groups in the execution view, add navigation bar at top of view (like Illustrator group navigation)
- Dave look at code for QBE & Indexing
- Also try to work with data

Groups/Subworkflows
- need more documentation
- better ways to view and navigate still needed

Documentation [Claurissa]
- Persistence
- Could use ListToDirectory to take a list of files and convert to Directory (use for example)
- Delete/modify persistent data
- Persistent data provenance [Dave]

Mashups in VisTrails [Emanuele, In Two Weeks]

Interface changes [Dave]

PythonSource updates [Emanuele]
- DeVide, Eric4

HTTPDirectory
- create a manifest file that can be used for HTTP directory
- check with Matthias for how this works, not supported by HTTP

Apr 1, 2011

Meeting time change suggestion to 10AM (Tommy) -- sorry Tommy, only now I saw this item...
- Next week: meet if need be
- Move future meetings to 10am if room is possible (Juliana checking with Deb)
Workflow Execution Explorer demo (Tommy)
- search interface for workflow executions
- thumbnails? problem is size
- can open a result and view the execution provenance
- querying vistrails
- materialize tagged versions in the database (so we can query workflows directly)
- extensions to allow query-by-example to work?
1.6.2 release (mainly with bug fixes) (Emanuele)
- integrate changes to module configuration? on master, wait for 2.0 to put in release
- investigate different options for Python editors
- users guide? change to use sphinx for this release, add new features for 2.0
VisMashup support in VisTrails discussion (Emanuele, Wendel)
Wendel will give a demo of his work on supporting interactive visualizations in Web browsers; and of his simplified version of VisMashup
- generate 3D view and parameter interaction just from aliases
- suggested parameters: can associate parameters from workflows from other vistrails to labels, also order according to prevalence
- data: allow user to select other datasets from crowdlabs
- how to identify parameters that occur in different modules
- identify aliases in the web interface
- creating workflow view
- how to store the provenance of such views
- save dictionary of values from the mashup with the executions
- workflow to mashup bridge
- also allow a mashup mode to start from
- assistant interface
Executable Pubs
- shell-escape not as well supported
- change the latex extension to be a preprocessing step (and make a vt_pdflatex cmd or something like that)
- Microsoft and MacOS X for publishing plugins--no Active X, known issue
- add better annotations to pdfs after the fact so that users can annotate papers
- meta-presenting
Manual
- packages: difference between wiki page and users guide
- split users and developers guide, may have to do this for chapters like ControlFlow
- keep list of questions, write emails, talk to people

Mar 22, 2011

support a subset of VisMashup within VisTrails: re-use subworkflow infrastructure, and add the functions which create the application. Similar to subworkflows, mashups could live inside a vistrail
- [DK] Note that mashups are higher-level objects than workflows. It would seem that mashups should include vistrails.
- [JF] My idea is really simple: when we create a subworkflow we are essentially creating a 'view' that hides away the details of the underlying modules and only exposes a subset of the parameters. What I would like to have is the component of VisMashup that takes a subworkflow specification and generates the app. This would greatly simplify the publication of *interactive* results. And I believe, it would be simple to implement since it would re-use the existing infrastructure we have for subworkflows.

support for global variables: maybe, an initial approach could be to have such variables associated with a vistrail. This would greatly simplify packaging of workflows, in particular, to deal with file locations in different systems
- [DK] We have discussed this before as having workflow-global parameters and have proposed a method for accomplishing this---namely modify the interface to hide global parameters. It may be possible to have them for entire vistrails, but note that this poses problems. Suppose a user that creates a workflow identifying 'x' (a Float) as a global variable, and then changes the workflow and identifies a new parameter as 'x' but its type is now a String. A per-workflow definition of the global 'x' is fine, but a per-vistrail definition is not. I agree that we should try to support some style of alias-like behavior so that a user can set parameters more globally, but it is important that these settings are saved as provenance as many of these might be per-session...
- [JF] I want global variables to simplify packaging of results. Having them on a per workflow basis would not solve the problem I had: In the WikiQuery case study I have a series of related workflows that all rely on the same set of input files; so in this case, I would need global variables at the VisTrails level.
- [JF] As for the issue DK raised, I think we could have a very simple solution: we check for conflicts with global variables and prevent the used from making mistakes

SubWorkflows in the database (Tommy)
- abstractions==subworkflows? Some error messages still refer to abstractions
- Logic for merging subworkflows from different sources? (Upgrading issues?)
Control Flow Assistant feedback (Tommy)
From Matthias:
- Remote execution: make it easier to move executions to clusters, starting them from VisTrails, waiting for the results. Can we make Joel's code for the wildfire simulations more flexible?
- Using VisTrails for validation: make it possible to take results of a workflow, and compare them with a previous result to validate that changes in code or VisTrails have not affected the results.
- Make it easier to select a persistent repository (test, release, etc.) so that the same workflow can be run against different repositories
- Better support for querying hundreds of data files (ie create a database of metadata that a user can use to filter the set of files to locate specific files quickly)
- Along with this, allow this to work over existing (non-persistent) repositories.
- A better python editor for PythonSource

Mar 15, 2011

database to file: works for log now
database: save subworkflows to the database
add uuids for vistrails, subworkflows, merges
merging: same uuid and data changed
look into distributed algorithm
merge should possibly include logs
allow additional metadata to be controlled, possible to have a 1-1 correspondence

speedup on database queries to speed up joins over entities, combine different attributes
loops on module executions
traversing module executions
build transitive closure
build table to link the workflow_exec with module_exec

fix for users-list problem with Embed GUI issue
how to handle users that want to contribute code or examples

[Dan] committing control flow assistant soon, issue with database version (see trac commit from today)

Mar 8, 2011

DB speedup finished? [Tommy]
- Speedup done.
- Looking into issues with saving log
- Execution Provenance API

Control flow [Dan]
- Fixed issues
- Input List Override working
- Cartesian product now working
- Error message with version tree
- Weird issue with the group executing before the map starts

Documentation [Claurissa]
- check in guide to git

Mar 1, 2011

Documentation Log

Updating the relational DB (Tommy)
- Import vistrail from DB is now very fast.
- Mostly done with export vistrail to DB. Still a few issues.

Feb 22, 2011

Python Source widget (Emanuele)

News: Claurissa will help us with documentation. She will start by translating the existing user guide into Sphynx, and then move on to updating the content as well as documenting the many features that are currently not described in the manual.
- Please add any undocumented features as well any (informal/incomplete) descriptions you might have to the following page: Undocumented Features

- focus issue (will ask Huy if he knows a good solution for this)

Browser updates (Tommy)
- project browser, workspace

Updating the relational DB (Tommy)
- insert size: Tommy tested with 60,000 inserts
- loading: multiple selects and retrieve them all at once
- incremental updates, is_dirty, is_new
- no need to bump the schema version
- start thinking about better ways to do queries
- can prepare statements via low level mysql commands

Loop Assistant (Dan)
- add tutorial for this loop

mailing list emails
- Dan: keep track of which emails and update the FAQ with answers
- Could think about putting this into a system eventually, but for now it's low-traffic enough

Feb 8, 2011

LaTex extension demo (Emanuele)

- New embed dialog

Non-modal PythonSource windows (link to discussion)

- make it non-modal, single window
- update selection on click

Where to keep User's guide and other documentation

- Sphinx, commit to doc directory

Log Explorer demo (Tommy)

Log_API RFC (Tommy)

Control Flow Assistant (Daniel)

Feb 1, 2011

Execution Provenance View (Tommy)

Control flow assistant (Daniel)

Script Interaction (Emanuele)
- CDAT feature that might be useful in other settings

Port/parameter management (Dave)
- moved close button
- what about NULL parameters?
- global parameters

Jan 18, 2011

VisTrails browser (Tommy)
- demo
- can import files and directories to the list of files
- can see and open vistrails, workflows
- need to think about how to show execution information

Control flow assistant (Daniel)
- integration with parameter exploration
- can re-use infrastructure with parameter exploration
- can keep provenance for parameter explorations for free if we use the looping constructs

New port/parameter management (Dave)
- demo
- ordering?
- ability to filter, sort parameters
- documentation
- required ports
- update modules to show when parameters are set on ports
- talk to Matthias

1.6.1 Release
- tomorrow, bug fixes + executable papers
- create tickets

Jan 11, 2011

Release (Emanuele)
- 1.6 released 1/7/2011
- there is a branch on git
- nightly builds
- bundling ALPS python support into releases

Control flow assistant (Dan)
- focus on supporting the Map module

VisTrails browser/repository (Tommy)
- open a vistrail get included in an index
- index includes vistrails, workflows, and executions
- use thumbnails for showing the workflows
- in the future, sort by projects

Port and parameter updates (Dave)
- Colin Talbert at USGS-Fort Collins requests the same global parameters feature that Matthias has already mentioned. We should start working on this functionality.
- Colin also asked about highlighting required ports
- Changes to schema: add required flag, cardinality flag, and global parameters
- Changes to execution: way to add global parameters and connections to workflow before execution begins (not display visually)
- Changes to interface: method to select ports and tie them to global parameters, global parameter display, highlight for ports to show required (red?), do we need to show cardinality?

Executable paper tasks

Dec 21, 2010

saving parameters in a module (email from Tom Maxwell, from NASA)
explorations still do not detect MplFigureCell modules inside groups or subworkflows

Dec 14, 2010

[ES] Unit tests
- Ran unit tests last week
- Errors with old versions of pipelines, need to fix pipelines
- console_mode_test can't be enabled

Data publishing with CrowdLabs
- using persistent files and directories?
- couldn't think about how to synch user directories with server directories
- look into how to push data files across with git
- how to organize data (ie persistent files) from a specific workflow or all workflows with specific parameters

[DR] Subworkflow upgrades: update--is it a wrap?
- functionality are completed
- one cosmetic issue -- disabling a package
- subworkflows move from top to bottom of the list
- [DR] Add documentation to wiki on subworkflow upgrade paths

[DR] control flow assistant
- started looking into this

[TE] Data/provenance browser: update
- looking at the old code
- some problems with the logs
- cannot find parent workflow
- adding project annotations to sort VisTrails into different projects, different vistrails in different project, need to have gui to do this
- synchronize when vistrail changes, especially with execution logs, create index schema for these files (vistrail and workflow exec)
- persistent data index, need to integrate eventually, scan through actions to generate list of files used

PythonSource editor
- seeing which PythonSource editor is open
- need to be able to have "save now" button or automatically save when someone presses "execute"
- generate id tag automatically, close the other window immediately
- highlight module being edited/configured, keep window open (like console, messages)

Lack of global variables and bookmarks
- don't need to reconfigure executions to do this
- just don't display the "global" modules and connections

[CS] look into 3 items for [MT]'s group: ports display, python source, global vars and bookmarks (and persistent files dump)

[PM] Merging master and crowdlabs git branches. How should we merge the crowdlabs branch into the master branch?
- problem is that there are changes in crowdlabs that can't go in the master branch (i.e. HTTPFile)
- [ES] just merge both so we don't have the crowdlabs branch
- [PM] change RepoSync to have a server config preference that is set to True for server, False for client, and RepoSync has an if in the compute that does one thing if server is true, another if server is false
- have a branch for workflow indexing so that patch lives in another place

Box input ports should be colored (e.g. black) if they are already set by an internal method. Another color (e.g. red) could be used to indicate mandatory input ports.
- Currently, non-optional ports are square, shown. Optionals are circles and must be enabled
- Add a third category for mandatory, problem is backward compat.
- [ES] Colors are already overloaded, not for ports, use shading instead?
- Also needs to be with global settings, etc.

1.6 release: [ES] already has 1.6 candidate
- don't include the new gui features yet
- freeze 1.6, just bug fixes
- merge crowdlabs branch

[DK] persistent files on the server
- [MT] has problems with files on server, issue with /tmp/, running older python (2.5)
- stress test, test on [DR]'s machine

Dec 7, 2010

[DR] Subworkflow upgrades
- Made sure that we don't rewrite actions but create new actions that show where subworkflows are upgraded
- Document what is implemented and how it works (at high level), also what isn't yet implemented

[TE] Errors and web services
- allow user to decide to only display errors to messages window instead of also showing popup windows
- Allow add/delete of web services from GUI without going to preferences
- Qt dependencies for error messages gone

[PM] Some specific questions
- Question: Should v1_0_1 MySql schemas be upgraded to v1_0_2?
- db_connection.begin() being removed, stale results
- memory size is too big for the field size
- [DK] check on schema changes, see what is important for changes

Question: do we display 'warnings' or only errors?
- Need to write ModuleErrors (maybe make ModuleWarnings) to the messages (debug) as well as adding as tool tips

Some suggestions/requests by Matthias:
- Support the grouping of vistrails and files into projects
  - Annotation here?
- Ability to set global parameters/bookmarks=workflows (e.g., a filename or path)
- Archive results -- create a big tar/zip file with all vt and results
- Ability to add a vt: if a node is deleted, all data associated with that should also be deleted
- Create a test suite: run a workflow, save and archive results (user could specify which results should be saved)

Data/provenance browser
- We need a better mechanism that allows users to search/query for workflows and provenance, for example search by project, parameter names and values
- One way to view this is to allow the creation of mappings between the vistrails/projects into different structures---like "smart folders", e.g., /projectN/vt1/wf3/exec23/O1....
- Support editing and synchronization in both ways (if edit smart folder, should update vt)
- Should be able to script the use of the browser, e.g., to test a new version of a workflow against a saved test suite
- Scientists like a directory structure and can go browse there like they browse files with finder/explorer
- Keep mappings from our datatypes to file structures
- Need an exportable archive (to send with a paper, allow browsing outside of VisTrails)

On merging master and crowdlabs git branches
- some updates on the crowdlabs branch need to be merged/patched into the master branch
- how should this be done?

PythonSource editor
- modal or multiple window editors?

Lack of global variables and bookmarks
- Problem is that aliases don't change workflow specification
- Need to store these values in the execution log
- Keep alias dictionary for everything
- [PM] Not a need for global variables above the single workflow level
- This already exists at the conceptual level---one module with connections to other modules, this just is cluttered

Unit tests
- [ES]: I ran the test suite on current master branch and 207 tests are executed of which 11 fail. Some of the tests are failing because console_mode_test package can be imported anymore (this is a package created specific to run console_mode tests).
- Most of the other problems are issues with

 InvalidPipeline: Pipeline cannot be instantiated:
 Missing version 0 of package <package>

Data publishing with CrowdLabs
- Using git to manage data between local and server data stores might be too messy.
  - Does one create a new git repository for each vistrail on crowdlabs?
  - The local persistent git repo holds all persistent data used on that machine. How does one push/publish just one data product using git?
  - Can anybody think of a plausible git workflow to do this?
- Perhaps we should just look into adding directory support for RepoSync module along with a better data management UI.
- Are there OS independent file transfer protocols better than HTTP? Something like rsync might work nicely, but windows support is limited.

Nov 30, 2010

Subworkflow Upgrades (Daniel)
- Should be completed finished tonight
- Local subworkflow upgrades should be working now
- Need to test these after the checkin
- Using a dummy controller

Assistant for control package (Daniel)
- Look at examples
- Try to make an assistant to modify workflow using currently selected modules as looping group

Improve error handling/reporting
- Tons of message boxes pop up when a workflow has a bunch of errors, UI response is bad after this...
- Update existing error messages
- Show Details rendering on Mac
- What to do when multiple errors occur in a single event?
- New dialog that shows "next message" but allows user to dismiss messages or view all in the messages window
- Color coding for messages: use gui/theme.py to configure: maybe try black for warning, gray for log level messages

Data and workflow browser (Nivan will give a status update)

Saving Explorations (Feature Request from ALPS)
- We already save parameter explorations with the workflow in the version tree. As is, we save only the last exploration that was done for a given workflow. If you ship the vistrail, the saved parameter explorations will be there. Is this sufficient?
- [MT] Yes, that takes us a long way. Could one add a button in the explorations to save a certain set of explorations as a new version, like you do with the camera angle in the spreadsheet? That way one could store more than one set of exploration parameters without forcing a new version to be created with every change?
- Eventually we should provide a selector in parameter exploration
- Fastest to just allow a null action new version (a bit clunky) but wouldn't require too many changes

Clean up/prune persistent directory
- What are the concrete use cases for this?
- [MT] Here are two concrete use cases that appeared over the last week:
  - a project is done, the important results copied to an archive and I want to get rid of all its intermediate files, etc., to save space - but not those files associated with other projects. Or, similarly, I'm done testing some workflows, want to remove all (partially buggy or irrelevant) files, and then start with production runs.
  - there was a problem in a workflow(e.g. a bug in HTTPFile module with binary files or a bug in some user code). I want to force a certain persisted directory to be "forgotten", so that I can repair the wrong files. Bumping the version number of the ALPS package would be one way, but that is overkill since it would immediately invalidate all persisted files. Removing the whole persistence directory is just as radical.
- just testing simple tutorials with small files leaves me with 2 GB of persistent data after 10 days, in 142 persistent directories or files. I need some way to clean this up that is less radical then removing all persistent directories and files. This could be done, by e.g. removing all those which do not occur in tagged or leaf workflows in a certain set of vistrails. Or marking those which occur in certain vistrails with certain labels, and then being able to prune all those with or without some label/tag. Another option might be having the ability to choose from various repositories.
- [DK] follow up on this

Improvements to VisTrails server communication with clients to better handle errors/crashes (Phillip)
- work in progress

Data Publishing with crowdLabs. (Phillip)
- Do we want data publishing capabilities in VisTrails and crowdLabs? YES!!!
- If so...
  - Currently limited data provenance for data. HTTPFile module lacks meta data, RepoSync module has poor usability.
  - Persistent Data works for experimental data. Can we use it for publishing data?
    - Publishing data or storing data on the server and pushing back and forth?
    - What is the current scheme for identifying data on the server?
    - Do we need to do better than the ids, versions, hashes that the peristence package provides?
  - Do we want to utilize data publishing software like The Dataverse Network or maybe Fedora Commons?
- [ES] Feature request: Can RepoSync support a directory of files?
  - [PM] It can't, and I'm not sure how add it. I also don't really like the current RepoSync interface. It's not obvious how your data is being handled, hence me bring up data publishing, so hopefully we can come up with something more usable/robust.
- persistence used more for exploratory
- want to focus on more archive
- move from exploratory data to published
- Dataverse: essentially a site to curate data, archive data, host their own site, each university has their own server, linked together
- persistent store integration: maybe use git to do this, can add to local repositories to move to git
- use some of the dataverse: standard hash schemes, etc.
- privacy: can users push workflows without exposing data
- permissions for who can check things out: download permissions, upload permissions
- look into setting up persistent store on

DisplayWall (Wendel)
- new version of vistrails receives rotate/scale messages much more slowly
- using the vtk version that is already there
- comparing VisTrails 1.2 with nightly src
- test when the messages are received on the clients
- [ES] Changed something in the VTKCell, using the Qt interactor from vtk now, just uncomment this (vtkcell.py file)
- some commands are missed; check why this is happening
- preferences switch? 2x2 not 2x3
- check what modifications exist in the client code that's not exactly 1.2?
- new version of vtk package changed some things
- update vtk upgrade: resetcamera and addrgbpoint => _# versions
- Demos on displaywall: Wendel has to keep both VisTrails running and stop work when visitors stop by unannounced

Relative paths in workflows, how to deal with them? (Emanuele)
- [ES] Updated all examples to use HTTPFile for these
- some of these had to change completely (color widget), kept tree the same format

Nov 16, 2010

Data and workflow browser (Nivan)
- Check into git branch (Dave)
- Add data support to the vistrails, workflows, and execs already exposed in the browser
- Add thumbnails to the browser
- Bittorrent support?

Upgrade issues -- a wrap? (Daniel)
- Fixing some issues with namespaces
- Upgrades for subworkflows that are included with packages, need to save these upgrades with the vt file as a "local abstraction" to ensure provenance. May be able to tie these back to the package versions once the package is upgraded.

Test Suite
- Matthias has his own test suite now
- We should make sure that our tests are up-to-date and run them before releases

Web services on users' guide (Tommy)
- Users' guide needs only a few changes. One of the changes should be a note making it explicit that we are using a new library and the old one was deprecated.
- Do we want to update the 39-page guide as well? For now, just update the users' guide. Don't distribute this guide. Just include it in a zip file that includes the old version.

Improve error handling/reporting (Tommy)
- print statements, has a new window
- add a menu item to view message window and also keep all messages from the session
- look into writing QMessageBox errors and warning to message window
- write all messages to a single window, write critical messages in red?
- have a utility method that encapsulates the gui error display and the core.debug display (if not running gui, only write to core.debug)
- don't display stack trace in a qmessagebox? -- try to emulate the invalid pipeline with "Show Details" button.
- make it easier for users to report errors by having a "copy" or "send to developers" button to report the details of an error.

DisplayWall (Wendel)
- What examples should be in the SVN? If we decide to keep some examples in the svn, some of them use data that should be along.
  - Indicate progress of HTTPFile
  - Had to upgrade examples to work with new examples of VisTrails
  - VisTrails can send progress information with another thread like crowdlabs can do
  - Each machine has a .vistrails and needs to download own version of data, make a single .vistrails for all machines?
  - All slave machines can use the server as a cache?
- DisplayWall Client on the Apple Store? I dont like the idea of sharing the client source code. And putting the app without login/password will allow anyone to access our displaywall.
  - Add a password for this
  - Do user management?

VTK package:
- Have two ResetCamera modules now
- Need to write upgrade code
- Only with vtk 5.7 right now
- Encode library version in the package version?
- For reproducibility, we probably want to stick to specific versions
- We still need some ability to run new versions of vtk for testing, new features, etc., too...

Relative paths in workflows, how to deal with them? (Emanuele)
- Should we use dataDirectory?
- Change examples to not use hard-coded files?
- Problem with workflows, not data files
- On Windows, use ../examples
- On Mac, use ../../../examples
- dataDirectory not used, I think
- create "$VT_EXAMPLES"?
- problem is using new versions of VisTrails, data may change so referencing old location will fail
- don't allow users to change this variable
- convert to use HTTPFile

Data files and the GIT Repository (Emanuele)
- make a separate repository or use the submodule git functionality
- go with submodule

Next release: What still needs to be done?
- high priority from ALPS list
- Dan's fixes to the upgrade workflow
- Date for release? Official release in beginning of December for ALPS
- All developers should run test suite on push
- Could make this somewhat automatic, run with nightly release script and email -dev list
- Could have different classes of tests, make sure that critical ones pass
- Tests have a bunch of errors currently

Saving explorations:
- Keeps track of the latest exploration for each version
- Check with Matthias what the requirements for this are
- Have way to send just specification to a server (run this workflow with this parameter exploration)?
- Can we have an xml spec that specifies the parameter exploration (export parameter exploration)
- Currently persisting via xml and then converting to string so we already have an xml serialization
- Dan wrote API that takes xml string and populates the param_exp gui with the appropriate values
- Need to back the GUI state with core state to enable short-circuiting the gui

Box input ports should be colored (e.g. black) if they are already set by an internal method. Another color (e.g. red) could be used to indicate mandatory input ports.
- Currently, non-optional ports are square, shown. Optionals are circles and must be enabled
- Add a third category for mandatory, problem is backward compat.
- [ES] Colors are already overloaded, not for ports, use shading instead?

Nov 9, 2010

FAQ
- As we reply to users queries, let's add the question and answer to the FAQ!
- Just a reminder

Caching of File module
- There was a message from a user who got confused because this module is cached by default (and silently). And in his application, since the file actually changed in between runs, he did not see the 'expected' result.
- Should we keep a hash for files and check whether they changed?
- Should we no cache File by default?
- [DK] File is supposed to have a special signature computation that detects changes in the file contents so this may be a bug instead. It does work, it seems to be an issue with the create_file
- [ES] In this particular case, the file was empty. He deleted the file outside VisTrails and executed it again. As he set create_file to True, he was expecting the file to be created again.
- [DK] Add random salt to hash signature when the file doesn't exist and create_file is True
- [JF: DONE] Juliana will edit the FAQ to note that the signatures are dependent on modification times

Claurissa will demo different ways to visualize the version tree
- weighting on various criteria for displaying nodes (importance from session, user, tags, etc.)
- other modes for viewing the versions (lists or timelines)
- often see only linear trees, teaching or thinking other than tree?

Upgrade issues (Dan)
- Vanilla upgrades should be in today's commit
- Added code so when doing upgrade to check whether the latest code is upgraded
- Two types of upgrades: (1) User changes the subworkflow, (2) Modules are out-of-date and need to be upgraded.
- Add higher-level features like "Upgrade All" for (1), "Import Changes to My Subworkflows", etc.
- Want a 1-1 mapping between unique subworkflow id and a subworkflow file (even if we copy the same subworkflow to different vistrails)

Offscreen bug (update from Huy)
- Mac issue when switching to Cocoa
- Huy added a QWidget for each of the render windows that is created, so should be fixed.

Gesture support
- Someone on Windows check the pinch gesture support; it doesn't work for Matthias under Parallels
- VTKCell is working now
- Cell dependent, panning now maps to middle button, pinch on the base widget
- What are Matthias's requirements here? Does touch gestures in the cells matter or only in the vt/wf views

Thumbnails: [JF: this needs to go to trac, for 2.0?] [ES: 2 tickets were created for 2.0]
- Resolution? -- [ES] problem is the size of the vistrail, but this can be configured
- Can we export to PDF instead of PNG? [ES] cannot display the thumbnail as a PDF in Qt?
- Can we have the option to save higher-res or PDF versions of the thumbnails
- Can we have preferences that allow users to save a higher-res or PDF version, maybe a checkbox
- Maybe associate a high-res version with a spreadsheet cell so that we can save a high-res version on demand
- high-res version associated with a version but allow user to initiate action from spreadsheet
- can we have thumbnails dependent on camera position [ES] doesn't like, user won't see exactly that image upon re-executing
- compact vistrail option by removing thumbnails

Tommy has rewritten the Web services module as well as updated all of the examples
- Server for one of the examples seems to be down
- Need to update the manual

Improve error handling/reporting (Tommy)
- Maybe display the intialization messages with the splash screen?
- Debugging levels have no way to access debug level
- Tommy takes first cut at trying to determine how to map print statements, notes those he is unsure of
- Developer guidelines for debug usage, use them instead of print statements in the futur

Merge functionality (Tommy) [JF: Cool!]
- Can now merge an existing vistrail into your own vistrail using menu item

Improvements to VisTrails server communication with clients to better handle errors/crashes (Phillip)
- [PM] I haven't had a chance to implement anything yet.

Data Publishing with crowdLabs. (Phillip)
- Do we want data publishing capabilities in VisTrails and crowdLabs? YES!!!
- If so...
  - Currently limited data provenance for data. HTTPFile module lacks meta data, RepoSync module has poor usability.
  - Persistent Data works for experimental data. Can we use it for publishing data?
    - Publishing data or storing data on the server and pushing back and forth?
    - What is the current scheme for identifying data on the server?
    - Do we need to do better than the ids, versions, hashes that the peristence package provides?
  - Do we want to utilize data publishing software like The Dataverse Network or maybe Fedora Commons?
- [ES] Feature request: Can RepoSync support a directory of files?
  - [PM] It can't, and I'm not sure how add it. I also don't really like the current RepoSync interface. It's not obvious how your data is being handled, hence me bring up data publishing, so hopefully we can come up with something more usable/robust.

Nov 3, 2010

Upgrading subworkflows (Dan)
- add updated versions to subworkflow vistrail and push to registry
- fixed bug with version/descriptor redirects
- key remaining task is to replace the box representing the subworkflow in the top-level workflow to reflect the change to the upgraded version of the subworkflow
- many corner cases, but we should get the vanilla upgrade (working) to git
- need to ensure that each subworkflow file has its own uuid; if a subworkflow exists in two different vistrails, it should have a different uuid (namespace).
- otherwise, we can get crosstalk where one vt can update the subworkflow from another vt (we can propgate changes to other vts via merges, but this should be a user choice...)
- enhancements:
  - allow users to merge subworkflows from a file into their own subworkflow (to incorporate outside changes)
  - latest version is the most recent non-upgraded version; if that version has an upgrade, use the upgrade
  - Next step: work on usability for controlflow package; explore Dave's idea of an assistant

Offscreen bug
- Huy is looking into this

Crash due to issues in loaded user packages (Tommy has fixed this)

Web services (Tommy)
- Package is completed, and all but one of our examples are working
- Tommy will test if the Web services will work when there is a proxy

Improve error handling/reporting (Tommy)
- we should have a single point for all error messages to pass through that is linked to both core.debug and GUI elements that display error messages.
- the goal is to implement a function that will be the single point for error messages, and that work without emitting GUI signals in core. As Huy suggested, we should have a GUI-wrapper which will be a no-op when the GUI is not instantiated---this will get rid of some of the pyqt dependencies (at least for the error messages).

Improvements to VisTrails server communication with clients to better handle errors/crashes (Phillip)
- Currently the VisTrails servers consists of: a single-threaded instance with GUI; multiple GUI-less threads
- We will extend the server API to allow clients to check the server status. The server will provide a separate socket and the client will be able to 'ping' the server; if the server is working properly, it will respond; if it does not respond, the client will have a time out
- The API will also support the ability to kill both the GUI-less threads and the single-threaded GUI instance. We can then restart the server components using Emanuele's new script.
- We should also allow users to set a per-workflow time-out; if the workflow execution takes longer than the pre-defined threshold, VisTrails will abort the execution

Update on fixing VTK Package (Wendel)

- It seems that the ParaView package has the same issues.
- Wendel has already checked in the new wrapper into the trunk; Emanuele will test it

Synchronizing VisTrails and ALPS releases (Emanuele)
- VisTrails latex package was extended so that python is no longer required. If python is not present in the system, instead of issuing a request to execute the workflow and retrieve the image from the Web, a local, previously saved image will be used. It is now also possible to embed the images of workflows into the latex file. Documentation about these and other features are currently in the README file and examples (example.tex) provided with the latex package.
- Windows and Mac beta binaries already include ALPS
- Are we distributing ALPS as part of VisTrails then? This seems backwards. ALPS should VisTrails as part of their stuff, no?
  - We will have separate binary distributions: one with and one without ALPS

Is a multi-touch interface to VisTrails possible now that it's supported by Qt? (Phillip)
- Yes, Qt 4.6+ supports multi-tocuh --- Huy will look into this; the goal is to make this work both for the workflow builder/tree view and the spreadsheet
- We still need to figure out what makes sense for multi-touch, however, do we have requirements from ETH-Zurich?
  - We want to map the zoom, pan, click, etc to multi-touch, so that VisTrails can be intractable on a multi-touch screen without a mouse

What is the status of the Vismashup i{Phone|Pad|Touch} app? (Phillip)
- If you mean mac binary, there's an alpha version here: http://www.sci.utah.edu/~emanuele/files/vismashup
- Do you mean iphone app? [Phillip: yes]
- Wendel will look into this
  - One of the issues is how to effectively handle images that are larger than the memory on the iPods and iPads---we need to process these on the server or use a model that allows the image to be manipulated on the client
  - We also need to connect the app with the crowdlabs server, so that the app can get the list of mashups
  - Phillip will investigate the feasibility of working directly with JavaScript and bypass flash

Oct 19, 2010

Update on Trac and Roadmap (Emanuele and David)
- Trac is now linked to git repository
- Roadmap on Trac has been cleaned up so we can hide completed milestones
- Tickets are being reassigned/revisited. Many tickets (24) are not associated with a milestone yet https://vistrails.sci.utah.edu/report/3
Synchronizing VisTrails and ALPS releases
Web services support (Tommy)
- discuss the interaction between the Web Services package and upgrades
Subworkflows update (Daniel)
Testing of new module drawing (Erik)
Aliases
- Currently, an alias is stored on a parameter. We need aliases to be stored at a higher level so that changing an alias is not a change to a parameter. The one issue is that there is a link between parmaeters and aliases in that an alias can only exist for versions that have the specified parameter. We might also have two versions where the alias points to different parameters. We could just store aliases as a root-level workflow element so that the set of aliases is versioned corrected.
- In the current implementation, the aliases parsed from the parameters are stored in a dictionary in the workflow, so storing aliases as a root-level workflows element might be the way to go --Emanuele 19:50, 15 October 2010 (MDT)
Error logging
- Suggest that we have a single point for all error messages to pass through that is linked to both core.debug and GUI elements that display error messages. This should improve our error handling significantly
PyQt dependencies in core
- Can we get rid of PyQt dependencies in core (and db)? This would probably require moving the signals/slots that we currently use to a similar Python implementation which shouldn't be too difficult. This would also require the specification of configuration widgets not as classes but rather some text that can be used to import the GUI elements only when using the GUI code. However, what would happen with workflows that run in command-line mode but require some graphical output?
Ports
- One annoying part of the current VisTrails model is that users are not given any visual indication that a port value is already set by a function or vice versa by a connection. In addition, we have no way to specify or enforce cardinality on ports at design time. It seems like we could allow developers to specify when a port should not be connected to more than one value (via a function or a connection), and give some visual feedback when a port has already been specified in one manner.

Meeting Notes

Bug regarding userpackages at initial vistrails startup causing startup to fail.
- Still an issue, ticket still open as a 1.6 milestone
Copy-paste bug
- Shortcut not working on Mac. Focus makes shortcut try to copy pipeline.
- Current fix appends to clipboard as users type - this is not a good fix.
Synchronizing ALPS and VisTrails releases
- 1.6 scheduled for Dec. 1
Webservices
- New library being used, but it's very low level.
- Simple types may cause problems with some web-services using complex or XML-based types.
- Need to make sure that this library can handle at least MOST of the web-services out there.
Sub-workflows
- Daniel's changes seem functional and very slick.
- A little more work on it seems necessary.
- Need some easy GUI mechanism to delete a subworkflow.
- Is the exclamation point in the module draw the best way to handle this? Make a tool-tip to explain it.
VTK Wrapping
- Changes to VTK Python wrapping is causing headaches - particularly in backwards compatibility.
- Method typing has changed to expect things like "List" or "Vector" - makes things hard on the user when defining these inputs.
- Removing List and Vector types and replacing them with dynamically generated versions from Tuples.
Aliases - Agenda pushed until after Vis.
Error Logging - Unify some error handling to improve how exceptions are dealt with. More on this after Vis.
Refactoring out PyQt dependencies from Core/Db/etc - Need to move all the signals/slots into GUI elements. Questions come when a workflow uses GUI elements as inputs. - More after vis.
Ports - We need a way of showing how a port is specified - function vs. input port. Cardinality must be established in these cases. Ordering on multiple connections should be handled in some way - whether it's just a documentation issue or a more fundamental one.
- Should we have a tutorial mode that bring up tooltips when someone does something new as if it were a live tutorial.

Oct 12, 2010

Trac and Roadmap (Emanuele): Emanuele suggested we should create a development roadmap and make it a permanent item on the agenda. The idea is to go through the Trac tickets and use them to build the roadmap that would be made public.
- go through trac and sort by priority
- add other suggestions to roadmap as well
- admins can add milestones via the admin tab
- David will assign tasks on list; those assigned need to follow up and check and fix them

Update on PythonSource error reporting and logging (Tommy)
- Need to make sure that all messages are printed through debug.X, so that the debug level (verboseness in preferences) is correctly used
- Can cut/copy/paste now
- Can we prevent the delete from happening?
- Phillip noted the spyder project has an interactive python console: http://packages.python.org/spyder/
- Can press enter to get to the end
- Need to check if this works or if we need to change
- Now have ability to see stack trace from the GUI (triangle menu)
- Suggest using a dialog to display trace when this item is selected instead of printing to console
- Also saving stack trace to the execution log
- Also printing debug information to vistrails log
- Add trac item to fix prints to use debug
- Try to fix core.debug to have gui.debug to eliminate Qt dependency

Update on subworkflow (Daniel)
- Notification when subworkflow is outdated triggered
- new_abstraction signal from registry in addition to new_module signal so that we can check if we need subworkflows to update
- How to display the possible upgrades (can be upgraded, can be upgraded but may break, etc.)

New utility added by Carlos (currently at scripts/module_appearance) to draw fringes visually, which generates output that can be pasted directly into the add_module call.
- Erik will test this on Mac and Windows.

Preparing a "Get Started" tutorial for SIGMOD repeatability
- Do we have instructions on how to use the latex package without crowdlabs?
  - links to actual workflows in latex
  - have README and example for latex in the source
- Metadata associated with VisTrails: should we have the ability to add vistrail-level metadata? e.g., who created the vistrail, its purpose, etc.
  - have pointers to paper to workflow and vistrails
  - add pointers to papers
  - allow access to add/edit annotations at the vistrail level
  - add GUI element to allow people to edit/add annotations

Maintaining VTK package
- have four classes that don't wrap, have error even in python level
- works well with VisTrails otherwise
- haven't checked the new changes from the wrapping
- Wendel will check on the new version

Web services package (Tommy)

Oct 5, 2010

Welcome Tommy!

Update on subworkflow (Daniel)

Issues raised by Matthias:

- need to automatically upgrade subworkflows. Currently it is necessary to manually upgrade a subworkflow whenever the version of one of the modules inside them changes.

- explorations do not detect an MplFigureCell embedded in a subworkflow.

@@ Line 7: / Line 7: @@
 === May 17, 2011 ===
-* Add coments critiques about the 2.0 changes [[Version 2 | here]]
+* Add comments, bugs, critiques, etc. about the 2.0 changes [[Version 2 | here]]
 * Global variables